Ann Richards: We Hardly Knew Ya or We Knew You Far Too Well
From my ex:
When Ronald Reagan died, even many liberals came out of the woodwork to praise him. So, it's no surprise now that they're falling all over themselves to get a word in about how much they adored former Texas Governor Ann Richards, who died in Austin last week. But all the commentary makes it seem like they're lamenting the removal of their favorite character on "Desperate Housewives", instead of talking about what Ann Richards actually did or stood for.
So, she was "feisty" and it was just a riot when she dressed up in leather and got on that Harley. Governor Richards sure was a barrel of fun. Unless, of course, you were in prison, on death row, or a death penalty lawyer. Richards oversaw the largest prison expansion in the entire history of the United States up to that point. And during her four years in the Governor's Mansion, she presided over 50 executions. Her defenders point out that the governor only has the power to briefly postpone an execution pending further review by the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles. Of course, they fail to mention that most members of the Board are appointed by the governor - including the chairman, who according to the Texas Administrative Code serves "at the pleasure of the governor" (RULE §141.1). Given the notorious unfairness of the Texas justice system, under her watch Richards could have easily instructed the Board to commute all death sentences they reviewed to life in prison. And absolutely no excuse can be made for her callously signing the death warrant of Johnny Frank Garrett, a man who Amnesty International cited as being "extremely mentally impaired, chronically psychotic and brain-damaged." The organization further states that a mental health expert described Garrett as "one of the most virulent histories of abuse and neglect...I have encountered in 28 years of practice." Shameful.
Yes, Richards did appoint some women, gays and lesbians, and people of color to positions in her campaign and administration. But with the 20,000 new prison beds she was so proud of bringing into existence, she caused misery for thousands more men and women--primarily Blacks and Hispanics--who were locked away under her stewardship. And no one can imagine the misery she caused for the families of the dozens executed under her watch.
All of this is what she should be remembered for. Progressives need to stop making excuses. We should all expect so much more.
-Quent Reese
Austin, TexasCompare with
Molly Ivins' column.
Also consider this story from an encounter Quent and I had with Ann Richards at an Austin cafe called Little City about 5 years ago (she was no longer governor at the time). We were enjoying our lattes on a crowded evening when Ann stepped in with a friend, ordered and sat down. As all of this was happening, Quent was fuming. He wanted to confront her, but I didn't and was concerned he would embarrasss us both. I was also still clinging to some miniscule hopes about the Democratic party. So he wrote her a note on a napkin about how she was a mass murderer and we couldn't stand to sit in the same cafe with her and we left it on her table on our way out. I think Quent said something like, "I just had to give this to you." She said "thank you" politely, and we left. For all we know she tossed it in the garbage fearing what might be written. Either way, we never saw her again at Little City Cafe.
This is all interesting because on a personal level she seemed to charm certain people; she neither transformed into a serpent nor injected us with poison when we approached her in the cafe. She still did a hell of a lot of damage to a lot of people's lives, and when you're in a position as powerful as governor, you can't make excuses later, and being personally charming could be taken as a sign of greater wickedness when combined with such brutal policies.
There are really certain things progressives shouldn't ignore in the politicians they choose to give their honorary "one of the good ones" awards. Certainly executing record numbers of people of color in a state with pitiful protections for defendants is one of them.
Is all this disrespectful at a time when the woman just passed away? I guess every human death is sad because the idea of death is kind of sad, though I can imagine circumstances when a human life extinguished could be a very happy occasion - the death of a dictator for example. But at some point we have to look beyond whatever pain we might cause the ex-governor's friends and family should they happen to read an account critical of her policies and counter all of the mythology being created in the media that always seems to come along at times like this. With that said, if any of Ann's family or friends happen to read this, perhaps they could reflect on the pain they feel and begin to understand the pain that the families and friends of so many killed on Texas Death row felt during the tenure of this "witty" and "charming" "true Texas icon."